Here is a quick question I’d like you to think about: How many people do you know who you would consider successful?
Follow-up question: how many people do you know who you would consider happy?
Are the ones you would list in the first category the same as the ones you would think of including in the second?
We just spent a considerable amount of time during the period from Rosh Hashanah through Yom Kippur speaking to God with our heartfelt prayers. We shared with Him our hopes and our dreams. We pleaded for lives filled with blessings. But what did we want most of all: success or happiness?
If you think they are identical you need to learn the startling lesson of Silicon Valley and its echo in the remarkable proximity of the holiday of Sukkot to the High Holy Days.
"I have witnessed so much success and yet so little happiness. In our valley of material riches and natural beauty, the two are regrettably too often in opposition.”
Silicon Valley is one of the most sought-after locations for the greatest successful entrepreneurs in the world. Steven Jon Kaplan, investment advisor and CEO of True Contrarian Investments, recently wrote that it takes “close to a $10 million net worth to be financially comfortable in the Bay Area – that’s a reasonable but certainly not a lavish lifestyle.” The area is home to those blessed enough to have fulfilled every standard used to evaluate success in contemporary terms.
But Silicon Valley has one pressing need that is not sufficiently met. In the words of a local prominent psychiatrist, Adam Strassberg:
There is a well-known shortage of psychiatrists nationally; however, more specifically, in the Silicon Valley Bay area, there is a tremendous shortage here locally. It is the nature of our supply and demand economic system – some of this imbalance is certainly due to supply, but I suspect most is due to a far greater local demand. I have practiced psychiatry in Silicon Valley for nearly 20 years, surfed the rise of the internet, floated with dot com bubbles and busts, witnessed fortunes and follies, all from the arms of my leather chair, in my tiny office, through a courtyard window, with two very ancient goldfish in tow. Everyday a parade of stressed-out 'middle class' multimillionaires marches through my office, on the hour, by the hour. I am indeed a 'Silicon Valley' psychiatrist. Over the decades – as both a psychiatrist practicing in Silicon Valley and a civilian living here locally – I have witnessed so much success and yet so little happiness. In our valley of material riches and natural beauty, the two are regrettably too often in opposition.”
It is the tragedy of our times that so many people are blessed with success beyond measure, yet so filled with unhappiness and discontent. Ross Douthat writes of “an immediate crisis, one that is killing tens of thousands of Americans right now – more than the crack epidemic at its worst, more than the Vietnam War. The working shorthand for this crisis is 'deaths of despair,' a resonant phrase conjured by the economists Anne Case and Angus Deaton to describe the sudden rise in deaths from suicide, alcohol and drug abuse since the turn of the millennium. Now a new report from the Senate’s Joint Economic Committee charts the scale of this increase – a doubling from 22.7 deaths of despair per 100,000 American in 2000 to 45.8 per 100,000 in 2017, easily eclipsing all prior 20th-century highs.”
What is the source of this crisis of “deaths of despair”? It is the result of a society that has so tragically confused success with happiness. There is a world of difference between the two of them.
Success is getting what you want; happiness is wanting what you get.
Success is having all the money in the world; happiness is having family and friends to spend it on.
Success is measurable; happiness is limitless.
Success is a fancy car; happiness is a joyous journey.
Success is working hard; happiness is loving the work.
Success is having everyone know your name; happiness is knowing everyone’s name.
Success is being right; happiness is being true.
Success is money in the bank; happiness can’t be deposited.
Success is private jets; happiness is flying high.
Success is never easy; happiness will never feel difficult.
Success is money; happiness is value.
Success is late hours; happiness is all day.
Success is second homes; happiness is always home.
Success is material things; happiness is in the materials.
Success is praise; happiness is never needing it.
Success is reaching the top; happiness has no ceiling.
Success is all the money in the world; happiness is needing none of it.
Success is doing what you love; happiness is loving what you do.
Success is envied; happiness is shared.
And most important of all: Success is measured in human terms; happiness is a divine gift for those who live their lives well by heavenly standards.
Sukkot is the holiday of rejoicing. In Hebrew it is called zman simchateinu – the season of our supreme joy. Its place on the calendar is not an accident. True happiness can only follow from our spiritual growth on the High Holy Days. Happiness is God’s gift to all who allow it to spring naturally from our pursuit of spiritual perfection, not the achievement of worldly success.
(14) Dennis Okpalaojiego, October 8, 2020 4:59 AM
Happiness is knowing that HaShem is with you every time , every moment.
I exalt HaShem Yisborach for making me experience both success and happiness.
When I had great success, I thought am happy. It is now that I have a little success that am experiencing great happiness.
Happiness in HaShem is the greatest success .
Thank you Rav.
(13) JACQUES VILLENEUVE, October 7, 2020 12:59 PM
A VERY POIGNANT ARTICLE!
FROM MY CHILDHOOD UNTIL I REACHED 16, I SAW MY FATHER STRUGGLE TO RAISE A FAMILY OF 6 CHILDREN, WITH PERIOD BOUTS OF ALCOHOLISM!
AS A RESULT, I WILL BECOME A MILLIONAIRE! THAT WAS MY ONLY AND SOLE AMBITION IN LIFE. AND OF COURSE, DID FLIRT CLOSE TO THE $$$!
AFTER 3 INDICTMENTS, 4 DIVORCES, 7 KIDS, AND 12 GRANDKIDS, I DO NOT HAVE THE $1,000,000, BUT AFTER 77 YEARS OF LIVING, MY LEGACY IS DIDCOVERING HAPPINESS AND THAT IS MY SUCCESS! BH.
(12) Gittel Katz, October 6, 2020 5:32 PM
Beautiful article for this time of the year
I read rabbi Blech’s book four months ago. Am Re-reading it for third time.
(11) Anonymous, October 5, 2020 1:05 PM
Deaths of despair are NOT the result of good old materialism according to Case and Deaton
While materialsm consumerism and equating money with success has tragically become the pervasive mindset of society, this is not at all what Case and Deaton define as the cause of "deaths of despair".
As far as I understand deaths of despair have been on the rise almost exclusively among white non-Hispanic blue-collar workers in America for the last two decades - and among black American blue-collar workers for the last five years or so . They are the ones most affected by deindrustialization, robotization, globalization, the new precarious jobs created in the service sector, rising economic inequalities, austerity measures following recessions, etc. And while all that is true for all Western societies, so far only the U.S. has seen a sharp rise in deaths of despair. (And the U.K. in recent years.) Angus and Deaton find the reasons for that in the lack of opportunity for affordable good-quality education, a uniquely weak welfare system, (the world's most expensive) market-based health care and an oligarchic political system (see the role of the drug lobby in the opioid crisis).
Thus millionaires might be depressed because they cannot find true meaning in their lives and that is very sad too but they are not the ones committing suicide or binge drinking or drugging themselves to deaths by the hundreds of thousands every year because they can see no way out of a cycle of a totally precarious hand-to-mouth existence in the richest country in the world. Millionaires needing psychiatrists (and probably largely because they too are victims of neoliberalism in many ways) , though tragic, is not the same as tens of millions of exploitated hard-working Americans fighting in vain to make ends meet despite holding down two or three jobs at a time, seeing their communities fall apart and ending up in tents by the feet of high-tech skyscrapers - a scene usually attributed to third-world countries only.
Anonymous, October 6, 2020 6:37 PM
I agree with you.
Hear, hear!
(10) Joseph, October 13, 2019 12:35 PM
Thank you.
Great article
(9) Theodore M Dunn, October 11, 2019 8:39 PM
Happiness / Success is not computable
To put it in a nutshell, if fewer were successful, would more be happy?
(8) Deborah Litwack, October 11, 2019 8:20 PM
great read
so true!
(7) emu, October 11, 2019 8:53 AM
Quite a mind opening article which has got me thinking & leaves the reader with no doubt as to its accurateness.
Quite a mind opening article which has got me thinking on the subject and leaves one in no doubt as to the accurateness of the article.
(6) Jaya, October 11, 2019 5:21 AM
Happiness .
I loved the list of distinction between success and happiness . Thank you for the eye Opener !
(5) Shoshanat Yaakov, October 10, 2019 9:49 PM
Beautiful and very inspiring article, todah rabah our dear Rabbi Blech!
(4) Rachel, October 10, 2019 8:40 PM
Deaths of despair occur mostly among those who are financially insecure
While I agree that our society unfortunately worships material succes, Silicon Valley millionaires are generally stressed but not despairing. People need good, connected relationships, knowing that family and community will be there for them, AND they must be there for others. Those who are better educated are more likely to be married Andy involved in their community.
(3) Alan S., October 10, 2019 3:34 PM
As always, an excellent article from Rabbi Blech.
I enjoyed the comparison of the success and happiness. May G-d grant you many more years to continue to teach and write.
Yasher koach and L'shanah tova Rabbi Blech.
(2) Bracha Goetz, October 10, 2019 2:20 PM
Wonderful!
(1) Anonymous, October 10, 2019 12:00 PM
Thumbs up Rabbi Blech, thank you! A healthy happy and sweet New Year :)