Jtube: America's Got Talent: Edon

Edon: Good for the Jews? Discuss.

Edon: Good for the Jews? Discuss.

This video encourages the discussion of Jewish values as they relate to contemporary culture. Jewlarious does not endorse any particular film.

Comments (54)

(36) S., June 24, 2015 1:57 AM

was reminded of the movie "The Pianist"

We should not have to look for approval and acceptance in the eyes of the goyim- whether the goyim are currently "good for us" or "bad for us" is just meant to serve as a mirror in terms of where we are holding in our own avodas hashem (service of G-d).

There is a guiding Hand behind history and whether things are going our way or not is not up to us or what we "accomplish" according to the criteria of the outside world. A talent is a gift from G-d and whether millions of non-Jewish viewers vote for Edon or not should not be the sole decisor of this kid's worth.

He is indeed blessed with great talent. And it's just that- a blessing.

Unfortunately the young man in "The Pianist" met the same fate as the rest of his fellow Jews in the Warsaw ghetto. The sad part is that although he managed to escape he still spent his days playing to the tune of the goyim around him...showing that for him, the ultimate measure of his success in this world still depended on what the nations thought of him....a sad situation indeed.

I wish all the best for Edon. Let us all remember that, as Jews, and as human beings, our true worth is inherent, G-d given, and not something that needs to be voted on by others in order to be valid.

(35) sara, June 17, 2013 1:09 AM

I agree

(34) Anonymous, October 19, 2012 9:23 PM


hmmm Is he not religious anymore??? not! Let the kid have his moment. A leaf doesn't move without the will of Hashem Isn't that what the tanach says?

(33) Anonymous, September 7, 2012 11:56 PM

edon is NOT making a chilul hashem!

i think he is amazing! its not like hes doing anything wrong, all he is doing is singing on tv. thats not against the torah! i think hes a talented singer and showing the world that jews are amazing! just as howie said. thats just my opinion... if anything i think him singing on AGT is a kidush hashem!

(32) Anonymous, August 29, 2012 2:34 AM

Edon is awsome

Edon is an awsome singer and i loved it when he sung what makes u beautiful it was amazing having it played on the piano!!

(31) Anonymous, July 22, 2012 9:03 PM

Who cares about whether its good for the Jews or not! maybe we should think about the kid. Hes young. think about what will happen to him with all the attention and media. If it could ruin Matisyahu who was in his 30s think about a 14 year old boy....

Becky Schreiber, July 31, 2012 1:07 AM


whirlwind von helwick, August 21, 2012 8:09 PM

I agree with YOU.

YOU are 100% right

BATEL, August 6, 2012 9:05 PM

i dont agree

i dont agree with you on this point i think that BEAOUSE matisyahu was in the 30 s it ruined him beacouse he want used to the attention he didnt grew up with it he got overwhelmed and cought up oin that world but this boy is 14 he will get usued to it he will know that he is a jew and that there is a difference between him and the goys he wouldent know any better besides he probably has a good encouraging family behind him who knows their kid pretty well and will help him to make the right choises . belive me they have spent some sleepless nights about whter to send their kid to america's got talent.

Anonymous, November 4, 2012 10:52 PM

I don't think this is right

good for the jews who knows all i know is that this will ruin Edon.. poor child!

(30) joe shmo, July 19, 2012 2:13 PM

amazing for jews

all of the people who thin that Edon is creating a chillul hashm are crazy. he is showing the secular wrld that matisyahu isn't the only one who represents the jeish world. i say Edon is a better representitve.

(29) Rochelle, NJ, July 16, 2012 6:33 AM

Good, Jewish radio interview shows he's in it for right reasons!

Edon explained in interview by Nachum Siegel on JM in the AM on 7/3/12 that he auditioned for AGT specifically to do a kiddush hashem...and he has by bringing glowing reviews from the judges about his nice image as well as his talent. As Nachum Siegel points out, he was featured on Shalsheles Jr. in the past. With G-d's help, he will no doubt return to the Jewish music scene soon, giving Jewish fans who already indulge in secular pop music more reason to explore the incredible diversity of Jewish music. You can hear the interview at http://www.wfmu.org/playlists/jm, just beware in the 3 weeks/9 days ending with Tisha B'Av (Sun 7/29/12) that the interview is preceded and followed by instrumental music.

(28) Anonymous, July 12, 2012 10:02 PM

I don't know if it is in the spirit of the 3 weeks or of Torah values in general to speak negatively about other Jews, even though the headline of the video suggests one to share their honest opinion. Honestly, I don't know if it's right to share our opinions if it casts another Jew in such a negative light. I think it's important to be careful what we say and how we say it.

Akiva Crown, July 15, 2012 4:52 AM

Mostly positive

Most of the comments show Edon in a positive light. At the same time, there are many others discussing Edon as a figure (not the kid personally) representing the Jewish people outside of this site. I was at a shiur this Shabbos and someone asked the same question as this site. When edon and his family chose to go on a national show like AGT, he sparked this national conversation about what it means for the Jews as he is representing us. Personally, I think he is an amazing Kiddush Hashem by wearing his Yalmukah, but it is fine that others feel differently. However, when someone chooses to be on national stage where they are judged by America, the Jews are going to weigh in as well. This discussion string is a real, honest and important discussion and it really had nothing to do with Edon personally, but what he represents. The worst thing we can do is not discuss what it means to us as Jews when we put ourselves in the public light and in a very secular world. I am not suggesting it is a bad thing, but we should all discuss that and figure out how we balance our Torah lives and our work lives. Edon seems to be doing it very well and I commend him.

(27) Miriam, July 12, 2012 12:56 PM

bad for the jews, good for the secular world

thank you aish for posting this clip and thank you everyone for the wonderful, diverse and sincere comments. in the 3 weeks, its wonderful to see so many diff opinions being spoken without arguments breaking out. that said, i think that edon is a wonderful boy, a real mensch, making a kiddush HAshem for the secular world. however, he is very possibly making a chillul Hashem for the Jewish world. for children who dreamed of joinign the secular world in any way, they now have the "opening" to do so. once one orthodox-jewish child, person joined teh secular pop culture, it makes it ok for everyone to do so. and not everyone can handle that without throwing off the kippah, or G-d Forbid the whole yoke of Torah. We are in golus and we must stay separate. we dont understand the fire we deal with when we enter the secular world.

Miriam, July 13, 2012 12:30 AM

I Agree But...

I certainly share your concern, however, there are Halacha-abiding and Torah-committed Jews who believe in engaging with the outside world (in almost every arena) even if it is risky. Not every Orthodox Jew reaches the same conclusion regarding how to respond to our secular surroundings, and it is important to realize that, especially when passing judgement on the boy.

(26) elaine, July 12, 2012 1:01 AM

behaving well can be Kiddush Hashem

I wish everyone who was so publicly Jewish behaved this well. His conduct so far is commendable.

serena, July 13, 2012 4:17 AM


loved Howies line and elaine, so agree with you... andnot just publicly jewish but a young teen... well done Edon

(25) Anonymous, July 11, 2012 7:12 PM

use for jewish

one should use one g-d talents for positiveness for our own people sing jewish for the jewish people .

(24) Chaim Yankel, July 11, 2012 7:02 PM

Deleted comment

This comment has been deleted.

Anonymous, July 13, 2012 4:18 AM

more ppl

i reckon more ppl here than the Bar Mitzvah!

(23) proud Israeli, July 11, 2012 3:05 PM

I think it's great that he's out there wearing kippah and sounds like an angel. We should all get together and help him in this competetion.

It's wonderful to see a Jewish kid wearing a kippah with pride. Why not show that to the world, and not shy away from it. We would not be discussing this if he was not wearing a kippah. We should help him get there by voting for him. He sings like an angel.

(22) Anonymous, July 10, 2012 10:11 PM

I think Edon is compromising his soul for fame during the "three weeks"

Anonymous, July 12, 2012 6:53 AM

Not True

I feel it is important to mention that Edon will, in fact, NOT be performing at all during the three weeks. The next round of the competition (when Edon will have to perform again) will be held in about five weeks according to the show's website. Even if we disagree with his decision, please let us all try not to broadcast false information.

(21) Anonymous, July 10, 2012 9:00 PM

He can't be only 14 with that emotion. Forget being one of us; he just grear

(20) Sharon, July 10, 2012 8:22 PM

Is anyone strong enough for that environment?

I would be terrified if any of my children were put into that kind of situation. I don't know if any in this generation is strong enough to survive the temptations that Edon will have to face. Yeah, it makes Jews look good -- but at what cost?

(19) David, July 10, 2012 8:10 PM

Good for the jews

What I think is good for the Jews is the number of people willing to vote for a kid wearing a yalmulka.

(18) CPerdomo, July 10, 2012 5:26 PM

Great Performer

Nothing new... Jews are some of the best musicians in the world... if not the best...

(17) Shoshana- Jerusalem, July 10, 2012 5:14 PM

low proile

The best thing for the Jews is to remain as low profile as we can. Rav Elchon Wasserman, may H-shem revenge his blood, wrote a pampthlet about this called, "The Time of Moshiach". But what can we do? We are tops in everything and very far from low-profile. If someone where to come from a different planet and know nothing about the Earth and just read the papers and listen to the media for a day or two, and throw in some science journals he would think that we were the overwhelming majoriy. One percent? Who would believe it? Certainly all this Jewish Jewish Jewish business isn't good. Read Rav Elchonon's book and see what I mean. (He was one of the biggest of the rabbanim during WW2, and was kolled in the camps.)

Yehuda, November 13, 2012 9:16 PM

The beginning of the redemption. Let Israel's light Shine.

We are in the beginning of the redemption now and G-d's message to mankind should come out. What makes this boy so special is not just his voice, but his kedusha. His inner sanctity and good character traits shine out and impress all of the peoples of the world. The peoples should be able to see that this is coming through the Jewish People. Then if they want to find more sanctity (i.e. G-dliness), they will have a direction where to look. " On that day, Hashem will be one and his name will be one" throughout the world.

(16) Mel Stewart Berger, July 10, 2012 4:41 PM

a great performance

Bring a musician and band leader for fifty-one years, I know musical talent when i see and hear it. Edon did a great performance. It was great to see him with his kippah on. I hope he goes all the way to win it all.

(15) Anonymous, July 10, 2012 4:08 PM

go edan win for all the jewish girls who cant full this dream

(14) Donna, July 10, 2012 3:50 PM


Howie's comment was in very poor taste and, for me, as a Jew, was embarrassing.

(13) Anonymous, July 10, 2012 2:40 PM

Kiddush Hashem!!

Edon is a huge kiddush Hashem. The comments that are being made about him as a person by the judges is a credit to what a mench he is. Way to go to his parents for raising such a fine young man. Regardless of how he progresses in the show, he has made a kiddush Hashem by his humility and midos. Good luck Edon!! We're all rooting for you!!

(12) Anonymous, July 10, 2012 2:24 PM

fantastic singer and a shannah punim

he is fantastic.... why was H. Stern NOT clapping at the end????????

(11) Steve David, July 10, 2012 2:24 PM

The Offensive Howie Mandel

In last week's competition, Howie Mandel praised Edon by trying to make a joke, first referring to his Bar Mitzvah (okay, no big deal) and then saying something like "Jew (instead of saying "You") gave a good performance." That Howie Mandel is himself presumably Jewish did not make the joke funny.

Eric, July 10, 2012 4:51 PM

low tolerance

The only question about Howie Mandel's joke is whether it's funny or not, because it's certainly not offensive. To be offensive one must examine the joke teller's intentions, and clearly Howie, as a proud Jew, would not want to offend a fellow Jew on national television. GROW UP STEVE and good luck Edon.

Steve David, July 11, 2012 3:50 PM

Just Plain Wrong

First of all, something is offensive if it offends someone, and Mandel's comment offended me. It was in bad taste and inappropriate. Why? Because substituting "Jew" for "You" in a sentence is a common practice of anti-Semites. See the 1992 film "School Ties" for an example. Now, I don't believe that Howie Mandel is an anti-Semite; he's just not funny. And if you find that his repeating an anti-Semitic expression is funny, then shame on you.

A Jew by any Name, July 12, 2012 3:49 PM

I am Jew, hear me roar

I understand your point of view, but I see this differently. I don't care what I'm called, be it Jew, Yid, even Kike. I'm proud to be one. If anyone thniks labeling me as a Jew is a slur, that's their problem. I wear my name proudly.

Eric, July 13, 2012 5:56 AM

Just Plain Wrong is a good title for you

How absurd Steve! You may feel things to be offensive, but that doesn't mean that they are. If a 4 year old has an aunt who is pregnant learns that as the baby grows the woman's belly appears bigger sees an overweight woman and asks her if she's pregnant too, is that child being offensive? The very root of the word is similar offense, meaning something that one actively does. If you choose to be offended by something that's not meant as offensive then shame on you.

Steve David, July 13, 2012 3:12 PM

Wrong Again, Eric

Using your poor example, no adult should be offended by a statement from a four year old, because a four year old doesn't know any better. But Howie Mandel is not a four year old, and he should know better than to use a common anti-Semitic slur. Jew apparently found it funny. I didn't. I found it offensive.

Gee Miller, July 10, 2012 11:22 PM

Edon made my heart swell with admiration and love for a blessed child.

Steve David...yes it was funny...lighten up. I see the brilliant smile and joy lighting this handsome boy's face, and I feel a joy any parent would recognize. Yes, he is an observant Jew...but Muslim, Catholic, or atheist would diminish not one iota of the talent and feeling Edon displays every note he sings or plays. We are all better for having had the experience of sharing this moment with him. It is merely a bonus for those who feel a sharing with him that he is a Jew.

(10) ekisheva kosmerl, July 10, 2012 2:22 PM

Yes Yes Yes!!!!!!!!!!!!!

May HaShem bless you and keep you, keep you true to Him and yourself. You make us very proud.

Anonymous, July 10, 2012 8:39 PM


(9) Chanala, July 10, 2012 2:18 PM

Deleted comment

This comment has been deleted.

Becky, July 11, 2012 9:33 PM


What you're suggesting is impossible... The environment you are in effects you... So as soon as he enters that world he'll change.. I think he made a kiddush hashem now just by appearing with his yarmulka as a proud jew. but I hope he doesnt win so he is spared the nisyonos. and we are spared the embarresment

(8) Harry Maryles, July 10, 2012 2:17 PM

Here's what I think: http://haemtza.blogspot.com/2012/07/only-in-america.html

(7) shimon baum, July 10, 2012 2:06 PM

Hes not going to win anyway.

(6) M Gilstrap, July 10, 2012 1:57 PM

Edon is good for us

My children and I have been watching this show from the beginning. Imagine their delight in seeing a singer with a kippah walk out onto the stage and belt one out. My 11 daughter wants to marry him!

(5) Tova Saul, July 10, 2012 1:36 PM

Fortunately we were spared from whatever Howard Stern said

Edon: Good for the Jews; Howard Stern: Bad for the Jews.

(4) David, July 10, 2012 2:03 AM


Sharron at 3:17 says "Oy"...lol

(3) Anonymous, July 9, 2012 4:25 PM

Dont know

Impossible to know what is good for Jews, Although its nice to see a Jewish face we must remember that were not honored when they like our talent and were not dishonored whey the don't we are the most important creation on the entire universe

(2) זאב קראוט, July 9, 2012 2:41 PM


I think just by wearing a yarmulka he is making a big Kiddush Hashem!

(1) Cholent Mix, July 8, 2012 10:50 PM


I think Edon is good for the Jews. Not any worse than Mattisyahu, definitely. But I do think that Howie Mandel's pun at the end is pretty bad for the Jews.


Submit Your Comment:

  • Display my name?

  • Your email address is kept private. Our editor needs it in case we have a question about your comment.

  • * required field 2000
Submit Comment

Receive Weekly Jewlarious Emails

Sign up to our Jewlarious Newsletter.

Our privacy policy