Yesterday, I decided that I would make a shiva call to the Haymans. Mr. and Mrs. Hayman lost their only child last week when a suicide bomber blew up Sbarro’s pizzeria in Jerusalem. I am sure you are all aware of this event.
Shoshana, their pregnant daughter, lived in my community in New Jersey. I did not know Shoshana, and before yesterday, I did not know her parents, the Haymans. So, I was not so comfortable going to their house, while they were sitting shiva with their family and friends.
I walked up to the front door, closed my eyes, took a deep breath, and then started to shake. I could not bring myself to walk through the door. What would I say? What would I do? How was I going to look at these people who lost their only child, and unborn grandchild?
How was I going to look at these people who lost their only child, and unborn grandchild?
My heart was racing. I clinched my teeth, and said to myself, "Renee, this is not about you!"
I tapped twice on the door. I walked in, and saw several people sitting around in a circle. I was not sure what to do. A woman invited me to sit next to her. I think she was a close family friend. I was silent for several minutes. I was very uncomfortable, and overwhelmed with sorrow.
I glanced at Mrs. Hayman just as she looked up at me. I told her that I recently moved to Passaic, but I did not know Shoshana. She took my hand in hers, and told me a story about Shoshana. She spoke to me for 10-15 minutes, holding my hand, and looking at me the entire time.
I knew then that I had made the right choice by walking through the door. I don't think that I have ever in my life seen such strength, courage, and trust in God. As Mrs. Hayman gripped my hands more firmly, and with the tears rolling down my face, I wondered if I would ever have half of her belief in God.
I thought that I would only stay for about 15 minutes, but 45 minutes later, I had to force myself to leave, as a friend was waiting for me to pick her up from work. Mrs. Hayman hugged me three times before I left, and as she embraced me tightly, she thanked me for being there. I walked out the door the same way I walked in it, shaking!
Sometimes sharing a tear is the only thing you can do.
I have met the Hayman's, and in some way, I know their daughter, Shoshana. I just wanted to share this experience with you. There are painful times in our lives. Sometimes, we don't know what to do, or what to say to someone in pain, so we avoid the situation.
I promise you, this is a mistake. Sometimes, just being there, and saying nothing is the best thing you can do. Sometimes just sharing a tear is the only thing you can do. And sometimes a warm embrace, even from a stranger, is not at all strange.
* * *
Memorial services for Shoshana (Judy) Greenbaum, the 31-year-old pregnant woman killed in the Sbarro terrorist bombing, will be held at the following locations:
Jerusalem - unveiling of the tombstone, at 5 p.m. on Wednesday, September 5, at the Har HaMenuchot cemetery in Jerusalem.
New York - at 11 a.m. on Sunday, September 9, at the White Shul, Reads Lane in Far Rockaway.
Los Angeles - at 8 p.m. on Tuesday, September 11, at Kanner Hall.
Shoshana is the daughter of Dr. Alan & Shifra Hayman of Los Angeles.
(14) Raymond, August 25, 2018 12:05 AM
So Sad
I know the Haymans personally. I remember all too well when their only child, pregnant at the time, was murdered. It was so sad. I remember feeling so inadequate in my attempts to console them, but they always kept their cool, at least on the outside. I do not know how they did it, because if I were in their situation, I would feel a very powerful mix of both hurt and utter anger. I would feel like wiping out every single one of our sworn enemies. Perhaps they felt that same way, yet strove to somehow maintain their trust and faith in G-d. Both of them are extraordinary human beings, to say the least.
(13) Katie Fiona Scharansky, July 21, 2011 3:33 PM
Kindness is never inappropriate.
You did a kindess - and at a truly difficult time. This act will be remembered and appreciated by many in that family and beyond. Well done you! With best wishes, Katie and friends x
(12) Anonymous, March 15, 2011 7:32 PM
take a step an reach out .
when my huabnd died 2 year ago i w in shock. a person in th community died adn idint know them and i paid a shiva call adn understood th persons pain. ikne wah it w like ot laose a partner. this wa an elderly man agonizing ove hs ded wife. i actually drew some strength form this shiva visit. al jews ned to rach out to othr esepcially now . we ae all in crisis! fraylach purim to all.
(11) Judy Glass, September 7, 2001 12:00 AM
I am touched by what happened and I know there is no way to change the fact that Shoshana (Judy) is gone forever. More painful is the fact that with her her unborn child died. We all have to remeber her forever and her love for Jerusalem and Israel even in dangerous times.
(10) Larry Melsky, September 3, 2001 12:00 AM
A very moving article about the strength of this Jewish family , in the face of such tragedy.
I just wanted to send the Melsky
family's sincerest and warmest
condolences to the Hayman family on the tragic loss of their daughter Shoshana in Israel.
Ms. Khotim, your article proved that all Jews are one, in time of need. Whether we know the family
personally is irrelevant. We as Jews, should always strive to aid and comfort Jews in need (financially or physchologically)
as you did with your shiva call.
You are to be commended & admired for your
thoughtfulness in paying the shiva call to fellow Jews in need.
Larry & Rena Melsky
and comfort
(9) Kishan Boddapati, August 30, 2001 12:00 AM
Very well-written ...
Towards the end, Renee had this to say: "I have met the Hayman's, and in some way, I know their daughter, Shoshana. " Well, this is in fact so very true ... there's an old proverb which says, "whenever someone dies, a little of us also dies!" [I may not have the quote exactly correct but am sure this is the gist of it. I was saddened with what's been happening in and to Israel in recent times but Renee's story really makes it quite more personal! I truly wish the bereaved family courage and strength in this dark hour.
On other note, I am by religion,a Hindu Brahmin but have a lot of interest in Jewish matters. One reason I read this article is the word 'Shiva' caught my attention ... in Hindus, Shiva is the name of one of our gods ...
(8) Miriam Kalendarev, August 28, 2001 12:00 AM
It all counts
I personally knew Shoshana Hayman and it was very hard for me to believe the shocking news. I do not know how her parents were able to live through this horror. It must have taken a lot of strength to survive this tragedy. I think it's very important to show them that we care. They need to see our support, our warmth, and our sensitivity. And we need to let them know that while she is not here with us physically she will always live within our hearts. She indeed left an eternal imression with us through her wonderful deeds. And for those who never met her will truly be inspired when learning about Shoshana--a woman of valor,a G-d fearing Jew,a person who dedicated her life to the service of Hashem.
(7) Dolores James, August 27, 2001 12:00 AM
'being there' is always very important.m
many times there is nothing to say be cause the pain is so deep, yet if that one person is present the pain is then somewhat shared between another.Words are not always needed.
(6) Rosally Saltsman, August 27, 2001 12:00 AM
I too visited the Hayman's and wrote about it.
AMONG THE MOURNERS OF ZION AND JERUSALEM
by Rosally Saltsman
I’ve been spending the summer on vacation. Although
it’s been a badly needed one, I couldn’t help feeling
a little guilty when I heard about the Jerusalem
explosion. Not that my being in Israel at the time
would have helped anyone, but I couldn’t help feeling
that I was not showing solidarity with my fellow
Israelis.
Shabbos brought me to the LaBrea/Fairfax area of
Beverly Hills where the community was feeling the full
impact of the Jerusalem explosion. Alan and Shifra
Hayman were sitting Shiva for their only daughter
Shoshana who had died in the Sbarro bombing.
Although the friend I was staying with only knew the
family by face and although I was a complete stranger,
we couldn’t help wanting to go to the shiva. Although
we felt uncomfortable, infringing on their private
mourning, we felt compelled to go. We went Sunday
morning right before I was to leave L.A.
Boxes of Kleenex were scattered among the many
visitors to the Hayman home as the visitors sat
weeping, unself-consciously. As we entered as
unobtrusively as we could, Shoshana Hayman was warmly
hugging what looked to be a very close friend. They
were obviously consoling each other while Alan Hayman
was stoically relating how for his daughter’s funeral
they had overstepped the tradition of not saying
eulogies at Friday afternoon funerals in Jerusalem.
Something they do only for great sages.
Shifra Hayman came over to my friend and I. When she
heard that I live in Israel she said "Thank G-d you’re
safe." I was overcome. She handed us Kleenex and added
as she saw our tears and our struggle to speak, "There
are no words, the intensity of people’s tears are
comforting." Shifra Hayman then hugged each of us
with great warmth and affection. Someone looking on
could have easily assumed we numbered among her
closest friends. After a few minutes, I turned to my
friend and said "I think they’ve comforted us enough."
It was time to go. Shifra hugged us again and we left.
Shoshana was the Haymans’ only child. They were still
basking in the joy of her recent wedding and
anticipating the birth of what was to be their first
grandchild when they suddenly lost both. At this
shiva, I had been given the rare privilege to see the
great strength of the Jewish people. It’s people like
the Haymans who show such strength and such love of Israel in the time of their darkest tragedy, and the
ability of communities to show support and share their
sorrow with them so deeply that makes us worthy of
being called G-d’s chosen. The greatest of human
dramas is not being played out in the horrors of the
suicide bombings where Palestinian terrorists try to
earn eternity by taking and destroying the lives of
innocent men, women and children, it is in the
aftermath of the destruction, where we see the
nobility of character demonstrated by the survivors
and mourners who console each other as they have done
after every tragedy that has been visited on the
Jewish people. When Jews and Israelis are sacrificed
on the alter of violence we are all counted among the
mourners of Jerusalem. May we all soon be among the
builders of Zion. May we merit to see Mashiach come
speedily in our days. In the meantime, may we all take
comfort in the unity of our people, in their love for
each other and in the fortitude of its many unsung
heroes.
(5) Lewis Ziman, August 27, 2001 12:00 AM
wonderful gesture.
I am a retired funeral director, and have often made shiva calls to families that I had never known before being called for the funeral. I had the same reaction to these strangers, who became close friends. I am the father of Chana Heller also of the aish family.
(4) Dina Blaustein, August 27, 2001 12:00 AM
Your Huge Mitzvah Brought Many Tears To My Eyes!
Ms. Khotim, I congratulate YOU for doing what most of us would not have.... paying a "shiva call" to someone we don't know. You have more courage and compassion than you probably realize, and we can ALL learn from you! I have sat shiva for both of my parents and found it most difficult. I didn't want to talk about their illnesses, or their deaths, to (in most cases) people that didn't know them, and to even those that did. I just wanted to "sit in silence" and just see a friendly face or get a warm hug from those I'm closest to.... What my parents and I shared is personal and deep in memories, that most of my wonderful kehilla (community) could not relate to, or understand. I commend you and thank you for representing all of us who would not have had the nerve to do your VERY BIG mitzvah. I'm sure you gave Shoshanah's,a'h, mother a great deal of comfort. Again, thanks for doing a beautiful mitzvah, for all of us!
(3) Anonymous, August 26, 2001 12:00 AM
Beautiful!!
Kudos to Ms. Khotim on doing a beautiful mitvah such as she described.
(2) Shari Hodges, August 26, 2001 12:00 AM
You have extraordinary courage and kindness
It takes extraordinary courage to do an outstanding act - disregarding public approval or disapproval - going on your own instincts - the basic tenents of the Torah. What a wonderful thing for you to do for her mother and family.
(1) Bonnie Cohen, August 26, 2001 12:00 AM
Dear Renee,
With tears in my eyes I read your article. I too have paid Shiva calls to families I did not know. Like you I felt that it was the right thing to do. May the All Mighty bless you, and continue to give you the opportunity to always be able to do mitzvahs.