Controversy surrounds the Prime Minister of Israel’s forthcoming appearance on Capitol Hill.
Invited by Republican House Speaker John Boehner to address Congress about the threat of Iran’s nuclear ambitions, Benjamin Netanyahu welcomed this opportunity to share his country’s existential concern as the Iranian regime comes ever closer to achieving the capability of fulfilling its avowed goal of the total annihilation of Israel. But the White House has made known its displeasure. A growing number of Democratic lawmakers said they would boycott his talk. Vice President Joe Biden, who as president of the Senate would normally oversee Netanyahu’s address, said he would be out of town. House Minority Leader Nancy Pelosi said she hoped the speech “doesn’t take place.”
Why all this animosity toward the leader of a long-standing ally, the only democracy in the middle east, to whom President Obama has long pledged his unswerving loyalty? Because the administration has made clear its fury at a supposed breach of protocol. The White House insists it was not consulted before the invitation was given. That breach of etiquette, it stoutly maintains, trumps any benefit Congress might gain from the insights of the Prime Minister of the country to be most immediately and severely affected by the present negotiations being concluded with Iran.
This isn’t the first time the issue of protocol lies at the heart of an Iranian threat to destroy the Jewish people.
Remarkably, this is not the first time the issue of protocol lies at the heart of an Iranian threat to destroy the Jewish people. There is biblical precedent. Eerily echoing today’s story, the Book of Esther recounts the first recorded instance of attempted genocide against Jews in the ancient empire of Persia, today known as Iran. When, more than two millennia ago, Mordecai learns of Haman’s plot “to destroy, to slay and to exterminate all Jews, young and old, children and women, in a single day” (Esther 3:13), he prevails upon his adopted daughter Esther, now Queen, to intercede.
But Esther is afraid. If she were to approach her husband to appeal Haman’s decree, she would be breaking royal protocol. “All the king’s servants and the people of the king’s provinces are well aware,” Esther responds to Mordecai, “that if anyone, man or woman, approaches the king in the inner court without being summoned, there is but one law for him: that he be put to death, except for the person to whom the king shall extend the gold scepter so that he may live. Now I have not been summoned to come to the king for the past thirty days” (Esther 4:11).
Nonetheless, the Book of Esther tells us that after begging the Jews to pray and fast on her behalf, Esther chose to disregard protocol in the face of possible extermination of her people. Esther succeeded in averting the evil decree. As a result, Jews to this day around the world celebrate the Festival of Purim.
In Jewish tradition, the Purim story marks the commemoration of a different kind of miracle. In its unfolding, it is a miracle of coincidences so statistically improbable that they together speak to us of the hidden hand of the divine in human events. For that reason the book of Esther is the only one in the entire Bible in which God’s name is not to be found even once. Here God hides His face - but is as much involved as when He split the sea before the Jews fleeing the Egyptians. For Jewish commentators it is the message of the famous – and ironically anonymous – adage that “Coincidence is merely God’s way of choosing to remain anonymous.”
And so perhaps the most remarkable serendipitous aspect of Prime Minister Netanyahu’s speech is that it is scheduled for the very day before Jews will be observing the Fast of Esther and Purim this year, to recall a time when a heroic Queen decided that the survival of her people took precedence over protocol.
(84) Neal Plotkin, March 6, 2015 9:02 PM
Bibi is no Esther
Comparing the selfish, blind ego of Bibi to the sacrifices of Queen Esther is the ultimate chutzpah. He does NOT, as he claims, speak for all of Israel. This was nothing more than shameless electioneering and cheap politics.
(83) SusanE, March 1, 2015 7:38 PM
Wow. This is disturbing.
So much hatred against my President. So much self-righteousness for everything you profess to hate about him. He was elected President of the United States twice in two fair elections. He deserves that respect from you and from your PM.
Benjamin Netanyahu may make the speech or he may not. It may be protocol or may not be. Would you think Israel could lose friends if, in his speech he shares the views expressed here by those of you that support him. However his name is barely mentioned in the comments. It's mostly hatred for my president. Would you have him stand in my country and read these comments out loud?
RichJ, March 3, 2015 10:17 PM
Hatred of Obama
He has disrespected and lied about conservative Christianity - the staunchest supporters of Israel. He has favored the Islamic enemies of Israel, he had retarded the efforts of the USA to stop ISIS, as well as those to thwart the efforts of Iran to wipe out Israel He has also done many things destructive to the USA itself. No Susan, if he is being hated it is because he has worked hard for it. You are simply blaming the people ho don't have their heads in the sand. There is an uncanny parallel to the origins of the Feast of Purim.
(82) Marie Devine, February 27, 2015 7:54 PM
Ester Went To Her Own King After Nation Called To Prayer etc.
Ester knew God was her supply. She called the people to prayer and fasting. She did not go to a foreign government or agencies to play God.
(81) Irving Bloch, February 26, 2015 2:54 PM
Love Bibi
The greatest man in this generation. A true and proud Jew.
Wake up and thank God for this great Jewish hero. He may be the savior of this generation
(80) Anna, February 26, 2015 12:45 PM
Bibi cannot be compared with Esther
I still believe in protocol with any world leader who is going into another nation. The political environment in Washington is very divided and for Nethanyu to ignore this fact is absolutely wrong. His coming will further divide Congress and the Executive Administration. Nothing gets done in disunity.
Esther prayed and fasted and took advise from Mordechai.
Esther saved a nation. Bibi worries about the nuclear threat from Iran but needless to say, Israel is not the only nation threatened by Iran nuclear program, it is also all of the Middle East and the world at large.
U.S. relations with Israel has always been very good. This breach of protocol will certainly add a greater strain.
I have my suspicion. The Prime Minister this time is more political rather than prayerful.
csndle, February 28, 2015 3:47 AM
Notice that there are those in Washington (one in particular) that rejects Israel and its leader and
supports its enemies. What's wrong with Bibi looking for support from others who might give it?
(79) Anonymous, February 26, 2015 7:05 AM
The Paradox of Injustice!
I am so dismayed at the impunity that DC is showing regarding a little thing such as an invitation, when they have of invitations flying around town all the time.
The real cover-up is that thousands of innocent people and animals are being tortured in this World and not an ounce of justice is forthcoming for them from Washington.
(78) Anonymous, February 25, 2015 7:15 AM
Putting politics aside, we cannot compare anyone of our generation to someone as big or as great as those mentioned in T'Nach. we have no comprehension of who or what these people stood far and we don't reach their tiptoes. furthermore, how can we compare a man who unfortunately does not recognize the importance of Torah learning, who unfortunately does not keep mitzvos, who unfortunately does not particularly like those who do, to someone as great as Queen Esther. He is approaching the situation with a tremendous arrogance. Esther and Mordechai approached the situation after 3 days of fasting coupled of course with deep prayer and repentance. If we would do the same, we would have a chance of survival. It is true that we must make some tangible effort in this world, but it must come with observing Mitzvot and calling out to G-D. effort without that is just gross arrogance stemming from a feeling that we have the ability to control this world on our own G-d forbid. G-D has put us in this particular challenge right now, and we must call to Him to take us out.
Linda, February 25, 2015 6:55 PM
Well stated Leslie.
Very good points Leslie and very well stated.
shifrabryna, March 1, 2015 5:27 AM
An answer to a misguided anonymous
You, anonymous, are a misguided religious Jew who may have missed a few of your lessons. You think that you are capable of predicting and judging who and what Hashem will choose to help or save the Jewish people? Bibi not wearing a kippah or keeping Shabbat render him useless as being a messenger for the Jewish people? The sheer audacity and chutzpah! If you were truly a learned and religious Jew, you would know that Hashem works in mysterious ways, and, yes, could use someone without a beard and a kippah to help the Jewish people. Maybe you wouldn't go to him to have him schect your meat; that is understandable and makes sense. To disqualify him as a servant of Hashem, based upon your religious requirements, is outrageous. Bibi is a hero to the Jewish people, and you should be praying for his success. Please don't mention what yeshiva you attended; your blissful ignorance would serve as an embarrassment to the institution.
(77) c hoffman, February 25, 2015 3:19 AM
It's all done for Bibi's own Glory -
Mordechai tells Esther -
Esther 4:14 For if you remain silent at this time, relief and rescue will arise for the Jews from elsewhere, and you and your father's household will perish;
Jews will be saved whether or not Bibi pulls his personal publicity stunt
(76) Elizabeth, February 25, 2015 3:07 AM
Fantastic!!
What an amazing article and connection!!
Anonymous, February 28, 2015 3:52 AM
What do animals and other people have to do with the leader of a good US ally coming to seek help for his country which is surrounded by enemies who would like to wipe it out?
(75) Anonymous, February 25, 2015 12:30 AM
I stand by everything I said appropriate or not. Obama is a snake.
(74) Feigele, February 24, 2015 8:58 PM
In the best interest of Israel,
We are talking about life and death of Israel and as such every single precaution should be taken especially not to offend our biggest ally no matter who is the leader and what his views are at the moment, at least until next election. We must safeguard all support we can get from them and not force their hand in the game, which might infuriated them rather than appease them.
Hank Himmelbaum, February 26, 2015 12:29 AM
I totally agree.
Bibi stay home and show respect for our President and the US that will never allow Iran to get nuclear bomb.
Stay home and enjoy Purim with your country men. By the way I have never made a contribution to a foreign election, but I will to your opponent if u show up in the US without President Obama inviting you.
C B Wells, March 2, 2015 4:04 AM
I concur
I totally agree with your comment Hank. I am not a U S citizen,and
my view is ;that's total disrespect to the US president and the US citizens. Period !
(73) Leslie Murray, February 24, 2015 8:43 PM
America needs this meeting!
I understand you are concerned about breach of protocol, but we NEED you to understand that the American PEOPLE are absolutely in solidarity with Israel, especially with Obamas denial of loyalty. Israel s the basis of our faith, and we cannot allow Obama to change what we stand on. Please consider allowing God to make this possible, without judgement, and know that the Prime Minister, in our view NEEDS to appear here to show our resolve in supporting Israel for the peace of the world. Obama is allowing the crumbling of societies all over the globe, and we, together, should join hands in solidarity to ring home the fact that the USA has no confidence in his leadership. Pay hard, and allow Gods hand to work for peace.
(72) tonna, February 24, 2015 6:41 PM
no breach of protocol
I may be mistaken, but it is my understanding that Congress does not have to request permission to invite a speaker to the White House. Therefore there was no breach of protocol. I believe that this once again exhibits to all who have eyes to see the true feelings of this administration.
(71) Susie Davidson, February 24, 2015 5:57 PM
Not the correct parallel at all - surprised at Aish
I am surprised at Aish, whose articles I usually find pretty evenhanded. Haman overtly planned to kill all of the Jews, and it was a concrete action that was scheduled and imminent. Yes, Iran says the same thing., but it is a different time where it would never be allowed to simply proceed with this plan without constraints implemented by the rest of the international community. Indeed, that is just what is happening right now to curtail Iran's nuclear ambitions. Netanyahu is no Esther. In her day, the options for political consultation, especially on a far-reaching level, were slim to none, and consisted of basically Mordechai and one's own thought processes. It was an autonomous world back then. In our current day, however, heads of state must abide in cooperation with official channels before lashing out on their own in manners that could be offensive and could have grave consequences. Netanyahu is acting in an arrogant and opportunistic manner without consulting with the Mordechai of our times, the official diplomatic world body. In so doing, he could be severely hurting Israel's chance for survival and for living in peace among her neighbors, by increasing her enemies. And it appears that most Israelis are seeing this as well, and have turned against him.
Brian A.Donnelly, February 24, 2015 9:59 PM
Don't be fooled Susie...........
May I suggest that the real issue here is the glaring failure of the US politicians to face up to the threat that radical Iran poses to ALL the free World. First the Jews and then to us, the rest of the 'unbelievers'.
Modern history also reminds us of another example of being 'blindsided' by an evil regime ( Naziism ) when the majority of the World did not even bother reading Hitler's crazy blueprint for exterminating the Jews ( remember "Mein Kampf ? " )
Here again we are being told in plain speak by Iran that their fervent wish is to drop a nuclear bomb on Israel - why aren't we listening and why does Congress refuse to even acknowledge the brave words of Israel's Prime Minister ?
Our eyes are clouded and our hearing has become dull in the face of this great evil.
As a devout Christian, and therefore a staunch supporter of Israel
and the Jewish people I say that this is the time when we need to stand alongside our Spiritual brothers and sisters and fight this evil that resides in Iran.
Shalom,
Brian A.Donnelly
Eion Isaac Israel, February 25, 2015 2:57 AM
Severe exaggeration
What Netanyahu is doing no way endangers Israel's Security in a Severe Way .There are Fixed and Flexible Facts and Chaos Theory is a Danger .
(70) Shoshana - Jerusalem, February 24, 2015 4:59 PM
pray
Before she rushed into the king, Esther fasted, prayed and asked the Jews to also fast and pray, therefore she succeeded. If Bibi would do the same, we would have nothing to worry about at all.
Mordechai, March 2, 2015 11:43 AM
Let's Do the Praying Ourselves
Shoshana, Bibi went to the Kotel (Western Wall) to pray before he left for his historic speech. It's now time for us to pray to Hashem (G-d) that he should annul our enemy's plans against us and bring us salvation, just as the Jews prayed before Queen Esther risked her life to save her people.
(69) Shlomo Karni, February 24, 2015 4:07 PM
Political spin?
Even in Israel, opinions are split as to the timing and manner of Bibi's speech to Congress -- with the upcoming elections in Israel. There is no doubt that he has Israel's security at the top of his thoughts, but the timing - and protocol - could have been managed better for all sides.
(68) Feigele, February 24, 2015 3:38 PM
Protocol or not…
One should respect and recognize the authority of another especially when positioned at such a high rank as President of another country and especially when they are one of very few allies, it is demeaning for anyone acting in such manner like going behind their back. One should ask that they first put their house in order before making any decision on which all parties agree upon. I wish and hope that this meeting will not take place without the approval of everyone. As for the analogy with Esther/Purim, each circumstance has its own consequence and merit.
Leslie Murray, February 24, 2015 8:55 PM
consider this first, please!
We have been so degraded as a nation (USA) that our prayers foe help are being answered by your Prime Ministers appearance. American citizens are ACUTELY aware that Obama is directly responsible for the crumbling of our society, and many parts of the world. Boehner was brilliant in extending this invitation to make it very clear that Obama works for us; we do NOT blindly follow like lambs to the slaughter. W patient with us, please, next to Israel, we're new here, and are being threatened just as much as Israel is it Iran. We just have to make this statement, and will welcome any statement of solidarity Israel will extend us.
Feigele, March 19, 2015 11:59 PM
All in time!
It is not question about making a statement or not! It is a matter of is it appropriate to go behind the back of a President of any country? I just hope it won't bounce back at Israel's face.
(67) Marvin Katzen, February 24, 2015 3:08 PM
Netanyahu
With so many people beginning to speak up about the arrogance and stupidity of Obama and his political hacks, it's important that Netanyahu, who represents a country on the front line speak his mind to our legislature. Obama quibbles while Isis leaves a trail of blood and disembodied heads, Iran stalls meaningless talks, while they continue to create nuclear destruction and the means to deliver it. We have an Islamist sympathizer who believes our nation is evil in the White House . America needs to hear what Obama wants to keep quiet. America needs to hear what Netanyahu has to say.
(66) Eric Fanwick, February 24, 2015 3:07 PM
How would the King feel if...
You make an interesting parallel, but let me ask you this question: How would the king feel if Ester bypassed the King and made her appeal directly to Haman.
The White House, even before Obama does not like to invite in the middle of elections, and I'm sure Israel's and Bibi's thoughts on the negotiation are well known even without the speech.
Bibi seems to think he is a republican in a country where most Jews vote democratic. I think he and Israel would both be better served if he maintain a proper non-partisan approach when dealing with the United States.
(65) Henry himmelbaum, February 24, 2015 12:39 PM
Netanyahu is treading into US politics.
He needs to follow protocal of the US. He is adding to his reputation of an ungrateful guest. He should have the acceptance of President Obama or stay home. This is Grandstanding and must stop now.
(64) Susan (syma) Rubinstein, February 23, 2015 9:52 PM
I support Bibi's Speech...Some of the Congressmen need a wake up call
All the Democrats need to remember how FDR turned a deaf ear when the Nazi machine was starting..We must learn from that history and not allow that history to repeat itself...Some of our politicians need to wake up. When these tyrants first go for the jews, Christians and others are usually next on their list as we've seen with Isis.
(63) Nadav, February 23, 2015 9:29 PM
Careful words
I agree with Linda's response. I would also add that care should be taken when equating, albeit with great subtly, the president with some kind of Ahashverosh. I've read similar articles equating the events of Purim with the "feud" between Bibi and the president. Bibi being the "Esther" of the feud and President Obama subtly being equated to "Haman" or "Ahashverosh". I have my disagreements with the president's policies vis-a-vis Israel, but there IS a protocol which must be followed. If you think Obama hasn't been cooperative with Bibi, after Boehner's dastardly deed in bypassing the president, I don't see a whole lot more cooperation coming out of this. Let's continue to pray for the geulah daily. Remeber folks, the outcome of Purim came as a result of the people doing teshuvah and rededicating themselves to Hashem. Without that, no speech in the world will change our fate.
(62) gina, February 23, 2015 7:00 PM
yes, it was true
It was true that the senate, as always trying to goad this president (something they didn't do with other administrations) did not clear it with the white house first. My take is this
This is an example of "turn the activity around"
. If our president , Obama, was asked to speak to the governing body of Israel, but they had not cleared it with the leadership, then president Obama SHOULD back off and not go to speak in Israel, also he should immediately take the time to speak personally to the Israeli leadership.
NOT to do so would definitely start up a hue and cry with gnashing of teeth against him, we know that....and well it should.
(61) David Schroeder, February 23, 2015 5:44 PM
Amazing parallel
As they say in the movies "God works in mysterious ways".
(60) Anonymous, February 23, 2015 5:26 PM
As usual
I enjoyed the article, especially the statement,
“Coincidence is merely God’s way of choosing to remain anonymous.”
However, I am circumspect about using the tale to justify a contemporary political motive.
Anonymous, February 24, 2015 2:25 AM
history...
Have you heard,... history repeats itself?
(59) Linda, February 23, 2015 4:42 PM
Nice anology, but it does not quite work for me
While your comparison of Netanyahu and Hadasa's beach of protocol is interesting, charming, and may illicit an, "Oh wow!" response from some, I think that yours is a failed comparison. A couple of very important details make it so.
Allow me to share them:
!} Ester was not invited to speak before the king by a known antagonist to the king or one who routinely defied and attempted to undermine and dethrone him.
Whether or not one agrees with his tactics, one must admit that John Boehnner has not only been oppositonal and antagonistic to Barack Obama, (excuse me PRESIDENT Barack Obama), but has worked tirelessly to remove, defy, disrespect, and sabotage him. Senator Boehnner has been so obsessed with THAT agenda as to the neglect weighty national problems.
Ester would have been fool hardy to try to engage the king in alliance with and at the invitation of one of his most ardent opponent and I think that Netanyahu is likewise. I view his 'breach of protocol' as reckless and unwsie.
2) Ester did not have anamist or make prejorative statements against the king whose support and protection she solicited. The same cannot be said relative to Benjamin Netanyahu's words and actions pertaining to the POUS - a man, by the way, who continues to deliver substantial monetary and military aid to Israel.
So while your article is clever, I humbly and respectfully submit thaI your comparison is terribly short-sighted and biased.
Queen Ester's wisdom, G-d directed strategy, and G-d given favor (and thus success), should NOTbe likened to what I consider Prime Minister Netanyahu's ego driven failure of wisdom.
Dave, February 23, 2015 8:15 PM
Very good points
Rachel, February 23, 2015 8:59 PM
Protocol in the modern world is achieved by mutual agreement
Ahasuerus was an absolute monarch who had already murdered one wife.
Fortunately, democratic governments today do not operate this way. In fact, if Netanyahu went and begged the Iranian government to spare his people, THAT would be a modern analogy. Here, the Prime Minister is visiting a third country (however powerful) and vital ally to request aid against Persia/ Iran.
As someone who has represented the US Government at the staff level in international fora, the rules are there for a reason, i.e. so that every participating government's representatives know what to expect, how they will be treated, and how others will treat them. That is why actions such as the hostage-taking of US personnel in the Embassy in Iran in 1979 was such a heinous act -- international law protects ambassadors and their personnel.
There are many ways for Israel to interact with the US Government. For the head of Israel's government to just show up in another country to meet with its legislature but not the head of government sets a bad precedent.
(58) Eva, February 23, 2015 4:16 PM
Not true
According to what I read, it is not true that it was not cleared by the president. In fact it was.
(57) Oxana, February 23, 2015 4:15 PM
If the history repeats let it be for the Creator sake in the favor of all JEWS
(56) Anonymous, February 23, 2015 3:43 PM
Jews praying and fasting on her behalf
Esther 4:16 Go, assemble all the Jews who are present in Shushan and fast on my behalf, and neither eat nor drink for three days, day and night; also I and my maidens will fast in a like manner; then I will go to the king contrary to the law, and if I perish, I perish."
(55) Yacov Schonfeld, February 23, 2015 3:27 PM
Slight error
I generally enjoy Rabbi Blech's articles, as I enjoyed this one defending the Prime Minister's choice to protect the people of Israel, in any way that he can.
Rabbi Blech's comparison to Queen Esther's breach of protocol is quite apt. However it did not happen on the thirteenth of Adar, but rather on the fourteenth of Nissan, as is evident from the Gemara in Megillah, which describes Mordechai' consent to violate Pesach by fasting.
May Rabbi Blech's continue to give us his excellent thought provoking opinion's for many years to come.
Yacov Schonfeld
Lakewood, NJ
(54) KayDee, February 23, 2015 2:50 PM
Bibi's Speech to U.S. Congress
1) In this Country - it is the right of the President to invite foreign dignitaries to address the Congress. Not the Congress to extend the invitation UNLESS they have the authority of the President. They DID NOT get it. In fact the Speaker of the House admitted he did not discuss it with the President. Therefore, BOTH Bibi & Congress are in the wrong.
2) We do not invite those involved in their political elections to address our Country PRIOR to their elections.
Bibi, has no right to address the Congress w/o our President's invitation & should have stood up & shown that he recognizes & respects our Country. As far as we are concerned, he is NO FRIEND OF THE U.S.A.
Dvirah, February 23, 2015 5:09 PM
When You're Drowning
When you are drowning, do you care who throws you the lifeline? Israel is fighting for her existance - that's more important than protocol.
Also, according to your account, the one who breached the protoocl is the House Speaker, not Bibi. He has a right to accept any invitation extended, without worrying about the internal politics of the inviter.
Kim Niemi-Buhler, March 5, 2015 6:16 PM
In agreement.
Dvirah, I agree with your comment. There are things more than protocol. I'm thankful that Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu excepted the invitation to come speak to America's Congress. He's speech was excellent and needed to be heard for such a time as this. In my opinion his speech was right on time. I am for Israel, and I pray for the safety and protection of such a Great Nation.
Paul Kessler, February 23, 2015 5:19 PM
Reply to comment: "he is NO FRIEND OF THE U.S.A."
I don't know who this "we" is supposed to represent. There are very many of us in the U.S.A. that believe that it is our own President who is NO FRIEND OF THE U.S.A.
Mary, February 24, 2015 8:05 PM
Amen!
Couldn't Agree with you more!!
Morton Friedman, February 24, 2015 10:15 PM
Right of the President?
Where is it written that the President has that 'Right'? One could even go so far to say that the President has NO right to require the Congress to provide a venue for the invitee of the President.
The Congress does have every right to establish investigations, without any Presidential 'restriction. The only 'so-called breach of protocol' is that the Congress did not forcefully present its invitation to the White House.
(53) Jacques Villeneuve, February 23, 2015 2:38 PM
Timing is everything!
Every event in The Torah repeats itself and we all know that, Purim was the bridge to the 2nd Temple, just as this Purim we will see the final exile and the 3rd Temple, God Willing!
Thank you Rabbi for your insight!
YOSEF YAAKOV AVROHOM BEN AVROHOM
Anonymous, March 2, 2015 11:53 AM
Racing Down to the Wire!
Jacques Villeneuve,
With a name like yours, I completely understand how you can say "timing is everything!" As you imply, the Jewish people will ultimately win this "race!'
(52) Helene, February 23, 2015 11:04 AM
Obama hates Bibi and Israel he was not and is not qualified to be president he is arrogant and has his own addenda and part of that is to change the face of this country. Two more years he can do a lot more damage to Jews Israel and the U.S.
Anonymous, February 23, 2015 4:15 PM
Inflammatory Language Does Not Help/Tehillim Does
I prefer to say Tehillim than to name call. If we believe that H'S' is everything and is orchestrating everything, we believe that eventually good will come. It doesn't mean that we don't take action. Not all political leaders like each other. I have no clue and neither does anyone else other than someone who has been President what is like to be a President. Many people are arrogant. Everyone has their own agenda. Only G*d knows what will happen in the future.
(51) Moshe Levin, February 23, 2015 7:34 AM
Aish distorted issue of Bibi's coming to address Congress
Most of us at AIPAC, very strong and articulate supporters of Israel in both t he Republican and Democratic parties, are very disturbed about what Bibi has done in "accepting" Boehner's invitation because he threatens the bipartisan support we at AIPAC have worked very hard to establish and is at the core of AIPAC's success in gaining support for Israel at all crucial times. This is not an issue of simple protocol - it is a slap in the face of the President of the U.S. And we would respond the same way if the Dems had invited Bibi (or a Tzipi LIvni type leader of Israel, which can happen) and s/he accepted without even informing, let alone consulting a sitting Republican president. Furthermore, how would Israel react if a U.S. president accepted a unilateral invitation by Labor to speak to the Knesset on the issue of the settlements claiming that Israel must vacate the West Bank in order to bring a halt to the excuses used by ISIS and other fanatics to kill Jews in Europe?
We all know that Boehner's invitation has nothing to do with Iran, but with embarrassing a Democratic president in order to garner support for a Republican in the next election; and Bibi's acceptance has nothing to do with Iran but is all about his attempt to garner support of Israeli right wingers before Israel's March election. So Aish, stop playing the righteous Queen Esther - your twisting the issue is more like a plot designed by a guy wearing a three cornered hat, or should I say, a two-faced mask!
Joseph Apicella, February 23, 2015 3:38 PM
AIPAC
As an American I respect this stand byAIPAC. You represent the view of many of the Jews I KNOW?
Anonymous, February 23, 2015 5:13 PM
Already Happened
In the past foreign diplomats have visited Israel by invitation from many different groups, both in and out of power. The forum is not always the Kennesset but these diplomats have addressed the Israeli public and politicians openly. Israelis are less interested in protocol and more in the practical - like staying alive.
Anonymous, February 25, 2015 3:57 AM
Other venues available
Bibi has many available avenues to publicize his views to Americans and to Congresspersons without accepting Boehner's invitation. Bibi addressing AIPAC is perfectly fine and does not require White House permission. Addressing a joint session of Congress is a different matter.
SusanE, March 1, 2015 7:15 PM
A bad situation that shouldn't have happened..
I Agree
(50) Anonymous, February 23, 2015 4:34 AM
What is a protocol? Is it the same as a Protocol?
The New York Times claimed that Bibi had failed to notify our President of his planned address to Congress. Bibi Breach of Protocol? Prager claimed that Bibi had given timely notice, and that the New York Times had printed an obscure unpublicised retraction in a minor late edition. NYT Breach of Protocol, Bibi breach of protocol?
(49) Daryn Churchill, February 23, 2015 4:22 AM
Open your eyes, All you people!
Take a look around you; at the political climate,at the increase of anti Semitic acts. You better stand with Israel and support her. Obama is not friendly to Israel. Iran's leadership is deadly hostile towards Israel. Netanyahu is speaking up for all Jewish people. "For such a time as this."
(48) Bunny Shuch, February 23, 2015 4:08 AM
Bravo to Netanyahu!
Netanyahu is exhibiting great courage and intelligence in addressing Congress on the urgency of stemming Iran’s race to obtain a nuclear bomb, despite the fact that he may harm himself politically in doing so. The danger is not only to Israel, which Iran has vowed to totally annihilate once they are able to do so, but also to other Middle Eastern countries and even to the United States. The oft stated goal of Muslim leaders, especially in Iran, is in sync with the tenets of the Koran, which urges Muslims to have dominance over the entire world and to convert, subjugate or kill those who don’t believe in Islam, including Christians, Jews, Hindus and others. Hitler meant what he said, Stalin meant what he said and so does the Ayatollah. Obama has shown no inclination at all to truly rein in Iran's race to attain a nuclear bomb. At the same time, he is unabashedly aiming to influence the outcome of the Israeli election by trying to discredit Netanyahu, as he has shamefully done numerous times thus far by insulting him and calling him names, while in return, Netanyahu has acted with dignity and restraint. Obama himself has not followed protocol on a number of occasions, such as refusing to address the Knesset when he visited Israel, while Netanyahu actually did follow protocol by not accepting the invitation from our Congress until after Obama had been notified. (The New York Times acknowledged this in a correction of their original article. Bravo to Bibi! May his visit here be successful as to educating our Congress on the perils of a nuclear Iran.
(47) Anonymous, February 23, 2015 3:33 AM
History repeats itself
I am disgusted beyond belief at the sick commenters on this thread who want those Jews in Israel to just shut up and die so they can continue to worship their golden calf, barack hussein 0bama.
They are the reincarnations of the leftist ethnic Jews who sold out their brethren in Europe during the Holocaust, urging FDR (another anti-Semitic Jewish hero) not to listen to the Orthodox rabbis pleading for the lives of European Jews.
They are also like the "good Germans" who were singing hymns in church next to railroads, while trains passed carrying wailing Jews begging for their lives. The "good Germans" reacted with irritation, singing their hymns more loudly to drown out the voices of the Jews going to their deaths.
I believe we made a great mistake by ending excommunication. Several people on this thread have made clear that marxism and the destruction of America are their life-long obsession, and if their fellow Jews get in the way by living, they must be eliminated. HaShem, we cannot survive without your attribute of Justice!
(46) Fritz, February 23, 2015 2:54 AM
Improper protocol - bah! Humbug!
The White House is complaining because the Speaker over Congress invited PM. Bibi without first notifying the White House. Didn't the White House exchange for one military deserter, 5 terrorist who are ultimately bent on destroying Israel. This was done in secret without Congress' approval. So which is really a breach of protocol? Is being upset about a man (P.M. Bibl) coming to warn the world of Iran's nuclear death threats some great evil, or, is a man (the President of the US) who continuously usurps his authority and ignores Congress and releases messengers of the evil one back into the world whose wish is to continue their campaign of death and destruction in the world a greater evil or not? Now, what are you prepared to do about it? You had better call your congressman and senators and tell them to go and hear the Prime Minister and let them know that if they don't go, you won't go to the polls to vote for them! Show your support for Israel like Esther did. Your congressman work for you!
(45) Anonymous, February 23, 2015 1:37 AM
fac5s
Right or wrong if we do not listen to his words it be to late to stop
(44) Zsolt, February 23, 2015 1:26 AM
unity
Well it is amusing to imagine Bibi as Queen Esther...
Nevertheless the parallel is startling.
And if we want to continue with the Purim parallel at the end Esther got the confidence to brake protocol as the Jews, with the leadership of Mordechai united for her success.
As always Jewish unity saves the day, and this is what we should all be working on today as well.
(43) Robin Benoff, February 23, 2015 1:25 AM
proud of you Mr.PM Netanyahu
Im so very proud that you don't cave in when you believe in protecting and securing Israel.Am yisrael chai
(42) Nosson Campos, February 23, 2015 1:04 AM
Unlike the one we unfortunately are tuck with in America, Bibi's demostrates that his reposnsibility, and loyalty, is formost to the people he represents!
The survival of Israel is at stake now!
(41) betty, February 23, 2015 12:57 AM
liberaLs very much against Israel
I'm a conservative Christian who supports Israel 100 percent!!! How fortunate we would be to have a leader like you have!!! What I don't understand is why so many Jewish people in the states are liberaLs that support Obama??? Does this continuous anti Jewish behavior not upset them??? I'm not Jewish and it makes my blood boil!
(40) Mike, February 23, 2015 12:04 AM
Much to do about nothing
In this country we have something called "the separation of powers". The 3 main branches operate independently of each other. Congress does not need the president's permisson to have PM Netnyahu speak at the capital. Pres. Obama has done much worse than break with protocol. He has ignored the constitution and even sought to undermine it. Selling guns to the Mexican mafia (fast and furious) using the IRS to attack his enemies, empowering ISIS by withdrawing from Iraq to early, ignoring federal immigration law, using the NSA to spy on you and me. Give me a break. I hope Bibi speaks openly and honestly to congress and the American people about how dangerous the Iranians really are. We
deserve to hear the truth.
(39) jack, February 22, 2015 11:41 PM
the Obama reasoning is beyond belief.
If Castro or Abbas was coming to talk to Congress this Administration would be forcing everybody to attend.Jew haters all over the World can not wait for the demise of the State of Israel.
(38) LJ Moad, February 22, 2015 11:34 PM
Manhattan's visit
I truly believe our leaders are put in place for HIS choosing. We should treat them the same as Hadassah (Esther). I will! Toda Rabba (think you very much for letting me reply) WELCOME!!!!!!!! NATANYAHU!!!!! LOVE AND PRAYERS.
(37) Anonymous, February 22, 2015 10:19 PM
bibi's visit to un
in spite of the strong message he will deliver to the un, unfortunately it will fall on deaf ears. israel has been up this road many times and the results are always the same. it is not in their best interest to overstep the formal protocol that always been used to address congress by a foreign leader. the appeal needs to be directed at obama because bibi's audience cannot and will not do anything to solve the problem
(36) Alan, February 22, 2015 10:12 PM
Disagreement
I must disagree with the thrust of this article. Even Esther went to the king. No foreign leader would come to speak to the Knesset without first informing the PM of such plans and coordinating the visit. While Esther had no other avenues to warn about the threat, Bibi has plenty of avenues to discuss his views on Iran and the ongoing negotiations between Iran and the P5 1 nations. Bibi has deliberately sided with a particular political American party rather than siding with the US and, thus, his actions have imperiled Israel.
(35) Donald Gotshalk, February 22, 2015 10:07 PM
Protocal
There are finally signs that "political correctness" is starting to disappear as it should. Was Churchill politically correct?. Was Bill Cosby politically correct? Truth can be poison in recent American politics. I heard an unbelievable amount of Huzzzahs when America's Mayor Juliani spoke out this week. I hope American warriors watched how quickly he became demonized.
(34) Gadi, February 22, 2015 9:57 PM
Bibi care only about his re-election
What a comparison between Esther and Bibi. Bibi cannot and does not fight with Iran. He is fighting with Israel's only friend in this world. Bibi behaves like an irresposible teenager.
(33) John, February 22, 2015 9:12 PM
We need HELP!!
The United States (in name only by the way) can use all the leadership it can get right now. Despite BB's shortcomings, he's 10x's the leader of ANYONE we have right now in American politics. I suggest everyone at the speech take notes....
(32) alan ash, February 22, 2015 8:56 PM
kolhakavod bibi .
kolhakavod bibi . . he has the obligation to warn the world of this menace . . the problem is the world is not to smart
(31) samP, February 22, 2015 8:55 PM
The snub.
There are people with whom I so wholeheartidly disagree that to be acknowledged by them would be far worse than a snub.Rabbi Blech's article is so wise and insightful I am hopeful he is aware of something in the talmud which is a parallel supporting the blessing oin being snubbed by the wrong people, such as an evil monarch.
(30) cincinnati, February 22, 2015 8:15 PM
Thank you Rabbi Blech
for another insightful article. It is unfortunate many of the readers (inferred by the comments) are unable to understand it due to suffering from NYT overdose.
(29) Anna Silverstein, February 22, 2015 7:56 PM
Need reminder about Jan 30 NYT correction
The editors at Aish should have added the fact that no protocol was breached. This fact, which I only saw on your email, has been poorly publicized. Please continue to refer your readers to the NYT correction of Jan. 30.
(28) Ben Adam, February 22, 2015 7:55 PM
Not so much..
@Michael Friedman: I am sure you are a very good person, and mean only the best. For all our sake, please get better intel. Your current intel is lacking. Thanks for playing.
Peace and Love,
Ben
(27) debra, February 22, 2015 7:42 PM
Are You Serious ?
Michael, are YOU serious ? you think Obama is disliked because of bibi's actions....... how do you figure this. no one is responsible for any one elses actions unless they are held in a cult of some type.
actually Israeli's are not happy bibi is coming here so how can this be a ploy on his part for his re election. I believe he is coming here for the good of his nation, our nation the US and the free world.
he has the most knowledge about what is happening in iran and how close they are to a nuclear bomb... Israel and it's leaders are some of the most vigilant. bibi knows terror... he lived it, couldn't it be he does not want anyone else to go through the nightmarish hell of a first strike from iran.... and I speak of the united states... our greatest ally, especially in that region is not bibi, it is the state of Israel and what she stands for..her values are the same as ours..... they value life, we value life, the countries surrounding Israel do NOT value life, they see their glory in death....... and intolerance...
this has nothing to do with a stupid election... he didn't ask to come, he was invited to come... and what do our leaders do... they snub him... would they snub the leader of hamas, or putin, I don't think so... more ironic this could not be...
(26) Daniel, February 22, 2015 7:39 PM
Israel
I applaud Bibi, for his stance and integrity to stay a front runner for his people, no matter the U.S, or anyone else. A man of true leadership. In the oracles of time, it will be well noted that those who opposed him and found excuses to not defend the people of Israel. Will give an account in the high court of Yaweh. Look up O Israel for your redemption draws near. And your enemies will be cut asunder. Pray for the Peace of Jerusalem, knowing it will come to pass. Shalom
(25) Jordy, February 22, 2015 7:33 PM
Rabbi wake up
It has come to the news that the administration knew of the invite and chose to ignore it. Then Boehner acted but Obama was notified.
(24) Katherine, February 22, 2015 7:00 PM
Our president and administration once again wants to turn a blind eye and deaf ear to reality. Perhaps "fear" is what drives the animosity. Fear that the American citizens will hear an eloquent, honest, forthright speech from an educated, honest humanitarian who wants safety for everyone not just himself, a speech that would put the administrations demise into question.
(23) John, February 22, 2015 6:39 PM
Bibi's speech to congress.
Discount the false facade of America supporting Israel. The U.S. politicians have been feverishly trying to destroy Israel since 1948. People need to face truth.
Martlene Langert, February 22, 2015 8:11 PM
Much worse now
Maybe you are correct about the USA politicians trying to destroy Israel since it was formed. I do not recall any of that. What I do know is that Obama hates Israel, hates the Jews, and hates the USA, so it has been extremely worse since some of us made the huge mistake of electing him president. I am very proud of Bibi. I hate this Political Correctness stuff. Besides, was it politically correct for Obama to go upstairs to have dinner with his famly and leave Bibi sitting there? If I were Bibi, I would have walked out immediately. GUess I was never meant to be a diplomat and I wouldn't want to.
John, February 22, 2015 9:07 PM
WHAT?
You're a fool, we have Jewish politicians working very hard to do their best. Seriously, think about never writing or talking again!
Linda, February 22, 2015 9:16 PM
Many Americans DO NOT support Obama
Please, please, do not believe for an instant that all Americans support Obama's stance or other politicians who are against Netanyahu's visit. There are many of us who love and pray for Israel and the Jewish people; who strongly support Netanyahu's visit at this time. I know and believe, with all my heart, that God has an eternal covenant with Israel and the Jewish people, and I take advantage of every opportunity to bless both Israel and the Jewish people.
(22) Edward A. Morrison, February 22, 2015 6:38 PM
Bogus comparison with Historical Figures
Not mentioned in Article is real reason why this "Bibi" invite is inappropriate. The President has said time and again, we should not intervene in Israeli politics so close to an election in Israel. Of course, this speech helps this politician to appear more moderate as a candidate for re-election. It should not be permitted.
Barbara, February 22, 2015 7:54 PM
The truth re: the elections
You may think that, but Obama sent over his campaign staff to Israel to sway the elections Netanyahu is too strong a figure for him to contend with. Unlike Putin who just ignores him
Anonymous, February 23, 2015 5:20 PM
Not Relevant
This has nothing to do with the elections. Do you expect the US President to do nothing in an election year? Until replaced, the elected official is head of the country and has all the attendent responsibilty - up until the moment of the next inauguration. So Bibi is Israel's Prime Minister now and he is fighting for his country's existance!
Baruch Cohon, February 22, 2015 8:05 PM
A Valid comparison
The false element in the comparison is something else, Mr. Morrison. Israel's election is an excuse. Obama hates Bibi and favors Iran. The way he is trying to steer negotiations makes a fellow wonder how much the Ayatollahs are paying him. Ahashverosh loved Esther and listened to her, protocol notwithstanding. That's the difference.
Stanley Tee, February 22, 2015 9:02 PM
But if that's the case ....
How do you explain Obama meeting David Cameron just before the British election? You've fallen for the flimsiest of excuses.
Shimon Lesserson, February 22, 2015 9:04 PM
Duplicity
Hi Ed - if a genocidal country were working furiously to build a nuclear bomb that it has stated dozens of times they would use to bomb your hometown at the first opportunity, is it possible you would be quite so indignant about your mayor appraising the world of your imminent obliteration? Over a breach of "protocol"?
Shimon
Anonymous, February 22, 2015 9:09 PM
WHAT?
So then why did Obama OK V.P. Biden to meet with BB's political rivals before the election? LOL
marcella wachtel, February 22, 2015 9:33 PM
Allowing him to accept this invitation is not interfering in Israel Politics
Check past President Clinton's invitations during his term of office.
You might be surprised that nobody called it "interfering" in Israeli politics. On the contrary Obama is trying to interfere because his hatred of Israel has not yet had the devastating results he is looking for and his time will soon be over, Thank heaven.
Karolewithak, February 22, 2015 10:49 PM
Not so fast
So hypocritical as usual. If the issue was about not intervening in Israeli politics, then why did our State Department give two grants to The OneVoice Movement, a U.S.-based nonprofit group that is partnering with the V15 effort to oust Netanyahu in Israel’s March elections, received two grants from the State Department in the past year? Google that. Find the truth. Quit blindly accepting the lies.
DMogz613, February 23, 2015 12:34 AM
Bogus Excuse
It is kind of funny how Obuma pulls the race (Presidential) card, but then sends his operatives to Israel to help the opposition. He is the "Lie'n" King!?
Anonymous, February 23, 2015 1:50 AM
u s is doing every thing to defeat netanyahu
In theory you are correct the us should not mix in
Is it true that a team of mr Obamas experts have been sent from the us is renting office space in tel aviv and is actively supporting the reelection of any one but bibi and is very heavily funded . In addition the white house was informed prior to Bibis acceptance of the invitation . The ny times clearly retracted from its earlier criticism of Bibi.
Anonymous, February 23, 2015 2:30 AM
What about US government funding of Netanyahu's opponents?
If it's not OK for Obama to "interfere" in Israeli politics by allowing Congress to hear America's closest ally speak about a life and death issue, why is it OK for Obama's State Department to spend millions of dollars to support Victory15, a group dedicated to unseating Netanyahu? What's more, Victory15 is being helped by a group of former Obama staffers.(information from the Jerusalem Post and Breitbart News)
Norman Frazier, February 23, 2015 3:36 AM
'Inapproptiate' or Politically Incorrect?
I remind you sir, this is a free country; and Israel is a free country. We in both countries will not allow anyone to dictate or by innuendo persuade us to act appropriately in this inappropriate world.
sharon, February 23, 2015 3:53 AM
I'm an American and I stand with Bibi
Our President is a leftist and pro Islam. He pretends he doesn't want to get involved, but doesn't mind sending his Left wing campaign manager, et all, over to Israel to work door to door under mine BiBi and Israel's election process!
ruven, February 23, 2015 7:00 AM
idiot - politics has nothing to do with it
The fact that BO will even speak to Iran that threatens the existence of another nation is a disgrace in itself. Bebe is trying to protect his people, and will go to ANY length to do it.
(21) annie, February 22, 2015 6:22 PM
esther vs natenyahu
great article we need to pray for PM. i dont think evry jew in Esther time wd approved of Mordechai advice for Esther to breach protocol .she didnt need their 'politically correct' advice. if she had there wd no purim to celebratr . our prayers are with the PM
(20) Steve, February 22, 2015 6:19 PM
averting holocaust.
The previous prime minister of Iran said words to the effect that a nuclear Iran could wipe out Israel but that Israel could only inflict sustainable damages to Iran. The sheer insanity of that calculus aside, Iran now has ICBMs capable of delivering a nuclear payload to Israel.
There is much on the line and clearly the current administration has been unwilling to include Israel in discussions concerning its survival. It has demonized Mr. Netanyahu. Some Jewish loyalists to the Democratization Party follow suit.
Most Jews despise post-holocaust deniers. But even more dangerous are the pre-holocaust deniers--those who used wishful thinking to blow-off the signs of the times. I am talking about Jews here.
Rabbi Blech's insights are correct. Those Jews who still believe in God should pray that Mr. Netanyahu's message be thoughtfully received by Congress. That would take a supernatural act given the the preludes we have seen.
Brachah bat Mosheh, February 22, 2015 9:54 PM
Is Rudi Guiliani correct?
He's partially right---the commander-in-chief does not value either the USA or Israel. Keeping Iranian info away from Israel? Not clever. At least there is finally a Democrat in D.C. who can prove to the Jews that we need to vote Republcan.
(19) Judy Rosner, February 22, 2015 6:08 PM
Protocol, schmotocol
Couldn't care less what the big-eared one and his secondary goof-off think - they've both "breached protocol" only too often in the six years they've been punishing both our country and yours.
(18) Stan Auster, February 22, 2015 5:50 PM
not against Bib...BUT
he is not my country man. Wish he did not play to whom ever he thinks are his fellows. Some American Jews can never agree with his pronounced and acted upon points of view. i am one
Anonymous, February 22, 2015 6:35 PM
Netanyahu
And I am another...it's all about the Israeli election and nothing else.
debra, February 22, 2015 7:25 PM
Missing the Point
Stan, I think you are missing the point of the netanyahu visit here. First, he was invited, but.. He is coming here on behalf of all free countries to tell them of the peril not only against Israel, but as our friend he is here to warn us as well that after Iran nukes Israel, the US will be next, make no mistake about it... now those are your country men.. who better to inform us of the peril that Iran will hold when they are holding Nuclear bombs. Netanyahu, if he knows anything, he knows terrorism and he knows what goes on in his own back yard...he must, he has too ...how do you think he keeps his own country safe from gigantic arab states who want nothing more than to wipe Israel off the map..... all , everyone of our reps, senators, the president, vice president and nanci Pelosi should and must listen to the knowledge that comes from his lips... He knows from whence he speaks..... he has lived it... gratefully we here have not... and I don't think we ever want to... he can help us keep that from happening..... our greatest ally..is not the prime minister, it is the country Israel.
No he is not your countryman but his fellows are the free peoples of the world, inside free countries.
This has not a thing to do with Jews, this is about the threat of a nuclear Iran.
the prime minister has the most knowledge about what is going on in Iran, . you don't have to agree with his points of view, but I think you will agree that an Iran with a nuclear weapon will not only wipe away Israel...AFTER Israel the United States will be in confrontation from Iranian Nuclear bombs.
the western countries, the free countries of the world should really listen to this man, and listen well.
(17) Anonymous, February 22, 2015 5:37 PM
Dems, offer your seats to the public!
I wonder how many ordinary patriotic, concerned Americans would like to have a seat in the House if all those Democrats are staying home or going out of town while Bibi speaks?
Anonymous, February 22, 2015 6:37 PM
Netanyahu visit
How many?? None! Not I nor anyone I know...unless it's to throw rotten eggs...
Simcha, February 23, 2015 12:03 AM
Comment to the Amalakite
Are you Haman or one of his sons.
Am Israel Chai!
(16) Anonymous, February 22, 2015 5:16 PM
No Comparison
The only problem is that Esther was a holy women who listened Mordchai compared to Bibi....
(15) Michael Friedman, February 22, 2015 5:14 PM
Convenient, but not valid comparison.
Are you serious? America, including the Obama administration has supported and cooperated with Israel both militarily and financially. The only president to apply financial pressure on Israel was George HW Bush, a Republican. Netanyahu's greatest concern is his own re-election. Since Obama's election he has done everything he can to embarrass the White House and obstruct any hope for peace. Most of my Israeli friends, and many of my Jewish friends in the USA, have a hatred of Obama in a large part to to the actions of Netanyahu. The comparison with Purim is convenient, but not really honest. Yes, Iran poses an existential threat to Israel that we must seek to prevent, but the Torah tells us to sue for peace before threatening force. I don't understand why frum Jews, of which I am one, ignore this important Torah principle. I have no doubt that the US, under any administration will act to protect Israel if and when necessary!
Sam, February 22, 2015 5:54 PM
Bibi
"have eye bat don't see; ears bat don't hear"; That is applying to you and lefties you a like, Mr. Friedman.
Watch and see!
Boca Mom, February 22, 2015 6:13 PM
why do you trust Obama to care about us?
Serious question - I have not seen our president show real concern for Jews in any way. Where do you see his concern? When he says the attack in France was random people (no mention of Jews even though it was a Jewish market ever Shabbat?) When he does not speak up about and condemn the violence against Jews worshipping in synagogues in France, Israel and Denmark being attacked? Please tell me why you think he cares - I see absolutely no sign of it. All he does is defend Islam. I don't think all Islamic people are evil at all, but why is he so vocal defending Islam and not equally vocal calling for people to stop killing Jews and Christians, too, by the way? I don't see any action from him that shows he cares about us.
Anonymous, February 22, 2015 6:22 PM
Obama is a joke to Israel and most Jews
Take your blinders off...Obama is the one who has caused nothing but strife between Israel and the US because face it, he directly opposes everything Netanyahu stands for. We as an America stand by and unite with Israel overwhelmingly. Obama is not hated by Jews or Israeli's because of Netanyahu's actions. plain and simple he is hated because he has turned his back on Jews and Israel. If you were familiar with the Bible, you would begin to see that none of this is a surprise and that in the end times the US is not mentioned nor any longer a super power...God has made it clear that any nation who turns their back on Israel, He will also turn His back on them.
CJ, February 22, 2015 6:31 PM
Can't wait until he is out of office.
I have no confidence whatsoever in Mr. Obama. Somehow you think his "red line" would hold for Israel? Foolish thinking.
Anonymous, February 22, 2015 6:32 PM
Netanyahu
Mr. Friedman, you are absolutely on the mark and I thank you for your wisdom...it's too bad we have people like Sam who immediately start with the name-calling (what does "leftie" mean, anyway), when they have nothing of sense to offer. Ignoring them is the best response.
Michael Friedman, February 22, 2015 7:25 PM
Thank you
You're right! Thanks for your support. I'm sure I won't convince anyone who blindly supports Netanyahu or blindly hates the President.
Joseph Apicella, February 23, 2015 7:27 PM
I agree with Mr. Freidman
Mr.Frejdman representsthe views of the vast number of Americans. Bibi represents Israel.
Kris Shackelford, February 22, 2015 6:53 PM
Really??
Mr. Friedman sir,
Let me please say this loud and clear as politely as I can, Obama hates America and Israel.. That's the bottom line, in his heart he wants to destroy any people that love The G-D of Israel and The Torah, he is a turncoat for soton and his heal care plan is a joke, he is a muslim through and through.
Anonymous, February 24, 2015 1:51 PM
Amen
So true, sadly, Friedman represents way too many Americans which is why we're in this mess and getting worse by the day.
juy, February 24, 2015 7:43 PM
Saying something clearly and loudly doesn't make it true. Obama does not hate America. I doubt that he hates Istrael, but it's not his main priority, you have no idea what's in his heart (neither do i but i don't claim to, though I'm pretty sure he's not trying to destroy anyone,) once you bring the soton into the story, you stopped talking reason altogether
Anonymous, February 23, 2015 12:11 AM
Sue for Peace?
Since the revolution, Iran has vowed to destroy Israel. They have also repeatedly lied to the UN inspector, when they let them in. perhaps instead of lecturing others on Torah, you should go to Iran an see how that works out.
(14) Anonymous, February 22, 2015 5:12 PM
After praying much for Mr. Netanyahu, I came across this article. It came to mind that Mr. Netanyahu might be encouraged to know that some in the US welcome his visit and are praying for God's blessing and favor to be upon him. I sent a note via this link and thought others might find it likewise useful:
http://www.pmo.gov.il/English/PrimeMinister/Pages/ContactUs.aspx
(13) Ben, February 22, 2015 5:09 PM
Netanyahu DID NOT break Protocol
Dear Rabbi Blech,
I appreciate your attempt to show the comparison between Queen Esther and Prime Minister Netanyahu, but your basic premise is flawed. Netanyahu did not break diplomatic protocol.
See below, this story from Tablet Magazine, about the obscure "correction," after the NY Times widely misreported the so-called diplomatic breach, probably promoted by their "anonymous" White House sources.
Netanyahu Accepted Invite to U.S. Congress AFTER Obama was Informed, not Before
The Correction: New York Times admits major screw-up on Bibi’s so-called breach of protocol
By Liel Leibovitz, Tablet Magazine, February 5, 2015
For one whole week, I’ve been staring at The Correction.
I’m a fairly seasoned reader of the New York Times, and a frequent critic of the paper, but the more I gazed at The Correction, the more it gazed back at me, defiant. What the hell?
You might have seen it yourself. It was affixed on January 30 to a story that ran the previous day about Bibi Netanyahu’s fraught relations with the Democratic Party. Here it is, in its entirety: “An earlier version of this article misstated when Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu of Israel accepted Speaker John A. Boehner’s invitation to address Congress. He accepted after the administration had been informed of the invitation, not before.”
The Correction, as corrections do, ran in the very bottom of the story, but you don’t have to be an ink-stained veteran to know it belongs right in the lede. The story is a whodunit, and The Correction shows clearly that the Times got the wrong man.
For entire article: http://tabletmag.com/scroll/188814/the-correction?utm_source=fb&utm_medium=post&utm_content=The Correction&utm_campaign=feb2015
(12) Dorit, February 22, 2015 5:06 PM
Thank you for the Reality Check on Bibi
All I can say after these brilliant insights is haShem is With Us! Thank God!
(11) Mark Cohen, February 22, 2015 5:00 PM
Bibi being political again
Bibi Netanyahu is no Esther and the comparison is absurd. Netanyahu is a classic politician who is using the American political system in a cynical attempt to advance his own political career. And President Obama as well as many democrats and republicans are simply calling is actions for what they are. The sad part about it is that the message Netanyahu wants to deliver is important. It is Netenyahu who undermined his own important message. Let's put the blame where it belongs.
(10) benton collins, February 22, 2015 4:59 PM
Bibi knows what he is doing
There are those within and outside (the U.S.) of Israel who wish for Bibi to be removed as P.M. The cards are being stacked against him. Those inside Israel think that they will be able to attain a false peace- this will not happen. There are those in the U.S. who want to make a grandstand play so that Obama can state that he has earned his Nobel Peace Prize with a treaty with Iran. This also will be a dismal failure. Bibi knows that this may be the last time he may have the ability to make a stand against a nuclear Iran. There are many Christians in the U.S. who love Israel and its people. They have have many scoffers who do not appreciate their viewpoint. The U.S. is a divided country- more divided than she was prior and during the Civil War. There are those who want to turn away from Israel and it seems that their voices are being heard while those who support Israel are considered to be a freak fringe element, If there were to be a second edition of John F. Kennedy's Pulitzer's Prize book, Profiles in Courage, Bibi would be the first person written about,
(9) judy, February 22, 2015 4:59 PM
Interesting coincidence, but let’s not inflate Bibi into more than he is. He is no religious icon. There will never be a holy book of Bibi. This is a politically complex situation. Becoming very publicly involved in the antagonism between the democratic and republican parties in the US is probably not the best way to handle this. The only ones who’ll be listening are those who already agree with him. The others are so angry at him that they will not take in anything he has to say. In order for a message to be communicated, it has to be stated in a manner the listener will attend to.
(8) Ruth Hirt, February 22, 2015 4:58 PM
HaSHEM's WAY be done to Israel
Protocols are meant to keep legal order, man-made. It is not to be used to manipulate situations, not to silence Obama's not favored persons and personalities in world policies. World security, should take top priority over politicking via protocols that shield the schemes of a wicked leader like Obama.
(7) Lynette Fazio, February 22, 2015 4:42 PM
Mr. Netanyahu's speech to Congress in America
Excuse me if I disagree with the content of this article. The premise is a noble one but simply wrong in today's environment. First, it is not solely about Mr. Netanyahu's breach of protocol. It is about his timing. Our President has also asked Mr. Cameron not to come visit weeks ahead of his elections in May. It is not appropriate for Mr. Netanyahu to have an audience in our government so close to his own election. Secondly, and perhaps most importantly, the substance of his speech is well known to our citizens and the crucial security Israel seeks from Iran is obvious. However, at this critical juncture in our negotiations with Iran any interference by Mr. Netanyahu could possibly jeopardize these talks. So far, Iran has adhered to all requirements stipulated in the negotiations. Further sanctions on Iran at this point are not appropriate and our President has stated he will veto any bill to instate more sanctions. Mr. Netanyahu has no business inserting himself into our foreign policy processes. Further, and rather ironically, Mr. Netanyahu knows all this already. His imperiousness is simply unprofessional and unproductive.
Betty, February 23, 2015 4:37 AM
forign policy a joke
Please tell me what foreign policy you could possibly be talking about? Obama doesn't have one unless you are talking about that red line he keeps drawing!
(6) carlbarry, February 22, 2015 4:28 PM
Bibi Betrayed The USA
So let me see if I understand, as an American Jew, I am supposed to support Bibi, who betrayed the USA by releasing TOP SECRET information the President provided him with, and thus has damaged US interests? And I'm supposed to support Bibi, who has repeatedly SPIT in the face of my President? All because he has been crying wolf for 6 years by saying that Iran is always 6 months away from building a nuclear bomb? No thanks.
Anonymous, February 23, 2015 4:41 AM
Your president
Your president and mine is ruining our country and doesn't give a hoot about Israel! Wise up! you have
(5) Dvirah, February 22, 2015 4:17 PM
Historical Parallel
Another and more recent historical parallel: during a ceasefire of the 1948 war, when the siege of Jerusalem was briefly lifted, a delivery of food to the besieged Jews was opposed by the British diplomat Bernadotte as being "against the protocol" of the ceasefire. Of course, he was ignored by Haganah and the Jewish community who rushed food, water and essential supplies to their fellow Jews in Jerusalem.
(4) scott, February 22, 2015 4:03 PM
Netanyahu speaks for Israel.
I like President Obama. Voted for him twice. But his policies toward Iran are wrong.
I agree with PM Netanyahu going to speak to congress. Although american Jews think that blind allegiance to the democratic party is an imperative for American Jewry, it may just be suicide for world Jewry.
I'm thinking about American Jewry's conspicuous near silence about the Shoah. Keeping it a non-issue so as not to embarrass President Roosevelt. Good call guys.
If the US President wants to be treated as an ally of Israel, he should act like it. Easing sanctions on a country that openly funds terrorist groups bent on murdering Israeli citizens and with nuclear ambitions that would boost its ability to do so with impunity is not the act of a friendly nation or President. There is no room for negotiation. This is life and death. I dislike Republicans, but if they are willing to act to save the life of my family they may get my vote. I'm a single issue voter. I don't want Arabs to murder my family. If a President fails on that issue, then everything else is really irrelevant isn't it?
PM Netanyahu is the Prime Minister of Israel, not the prize pet of the American Jewish Community. He has to act to preserve the lives of my wife and child, not the electiblity of Democrats.
Netanyahu is not Esther. He has personal power and political ambitions. He's just doing his job not being heroic. I appreciate him but let's not minimize Esther.
(3) Anonymous, February 22, 2015 4:31 AM
Interesting fact
This is amazing --- just got it A friend sent this to me: Once there was a King in Shushan, the most powerful ruler in the world, who had a strong disdain, dislike or perhaps even hatred of Jews. Today there is a President in Washington, the most powerful ruler in the world, who has a strong disdain, dislike or perhaps even hatred of Jews. Once there was a Persian who wanted to kill all the Jews, but needed the King's authorization to proceed with his plan. Today there are Persians who want to kill all the Jews, but needs the President's authorization to proceed with their plan. The King didn't really care, as long as there was something in it for him - lots of money. The President doesn't really care, as long as there is something in it for him - a deal with the Persians. The Jewish Queen wanted to tell the King what was really happening, but going in to talk to the King was dangerous. The Jewish Prime Minister wants to tell the President and his Congress what is really happening, but going to talk to them is dangerous. Some people thought she shouldn't go, it would just anger the King and make things worse. Some people think he shouldn't go, it will just anger the President and make things worse. She asked the Jews to fast and pray for the success of her mission. They did so, the King accepted her words and the plot to destroy them was thwarted. Will we fast and pray for the success of his mission? Will the President and Congress accept his words? Will the plot to destroy us be thwarted? We commemorate the fasting prior to the Queen's plea to the King on Taanis Ester. The Prime Minister of Israel has been invited to address the United States Congress on March 3. This year Taanis Ester begins on match 3rd.
Mordy, February 22, 2015 12:43 PM
Betrayal of Israel
The State Department on February 18 put out a travel warning for the state of Israel strongly warning U.S. citizens not to travel there at all. There is no reason for this as there has not been any major terrorist event in Israel recently. Is this the "payback" that an anonymous source in the White House said would occur if Netanyahu speaks to Congress? On the State Department’s website, for their map of Israel, the Golan Heights which Israel annexed, has Syria's name on it! Furthermore, the map shows all the countries surrounding Israel, but Israel itself is nowhere to be seen! Israel has been erased! This is similar to Palestinian Authority maps that refuse to write the word Israel. Obama has a record of denying reality whether it was the “random” shooting of a “bunch of folks” at a deli (who were targeted because they were Jewish), or the beheading of “Egyptian citizens” (who were targeted because of their Coptic Christian faith).
This can be no accident. This betrayal of Israel on the part of the Obama administration is now proven beyond the shadow of a doubt. There also can be no doubt where U.S. negotiations with Iran are headed. May G-d protect us.
Anonymous, February 23, 2015 7:48 AM
Spoiler alert
What State Department Map is Mordy referring to? Not http://www.state.gov/p/nea/ci with Israel is at the center of the inset). Nor http://www.state.gov/p/nea/ci/is/index.htm, entitled "Israel" at the top and showing the Golan as occupied territory with the same legal status as the West Bank.
Mordy also fundamentally misrepresents the travel advisory, which covers not just Israel but also Gaza and the occupied territories in the Golan and West Bank. It is is far more detailed and complex than a flat don't-go-there. For example, it states, "Personal safety conditions in major metropolitan areas, including Tel Aviv and Haifa and surrounding regions, are comparable to other major global cities." By comparison, "The Department of State strongly warns U.S. citizens against travel to the Gaza Strip" and "The Department of State urges U.S. citizens to exercise caution when traveling to the West Bank." Elsewhere, and especially within the pre-1967 borders Green Line, it merely urges more caution than usual. Given the heightened state of tensions and random attacks in recent weeks, that hardly seems like bad advice.
Mordy, February 23, 2015 10:18 AM
Rebutal
Anonymous,I'm referring to http://travel.state.gov/content/passports/english/alertswarnings/israel-travel-warning.html which is the map shown with the travel warning to Israel. The title of the map says Israel, West Bank and Gaza, but in the map itself, there is NO mention of Israel, unlike the West Bank and Gaza who are mentioned by name. Nice try, but no cigar. This is NO accident. Furthermore, in its Travel Warnings explanation, the State Dept. writes and I quote: "We issue a Travel Warning when we want you to consider very carefully whether you should go to a country at all. Examples of reasons for issuing a Travel Warning might include unstable government, civil war, ongoing intense crime or violence, or frequent terrorist attacks. We want you to know the risks of traveling to these places and to strongly consider not going to them at all. Travel Warnings remain in place until the situation changes; some have been in effect for years." This does not merely urge more caution than usual, as you say. This recommends not going to these areas, Israel included. Case closed.
Mordy, February 23, 2015 5:29 PM
You are Right on One Point
to Anonymous: I concede on one point you made. I noticed that in its maps for all countries of the world, the State Department never writes the country on the map, but as a title above the map. My other points remain, namely that they grant Syrian sovereignty to the Golan Heights by putting Syria's name there, and unjustifiably put Israel on the list of travel warnings, strongly suggesting not to travel there. (Look at their definition of travel warnings-http://travel.state.gov/content/passports/english/alertswarnings.html This remains a betrayal of the State of Israel.
(2) Anonymous, February 22, 2015 3:07 AM
Shevet Binyamin
Interesting - Esther came from shevet Binyamin.
Both Obama and Ahashveirosh's legitimacy have been suspect. One married into the position and one has never produced a birth certificate to show his origins.
Anonymous, February 23, 2015 9:13 PM
Birther nonsense
President Obama's birth certificate is available online at whitehouse.gov, just put in the search term birth certificate.
Furthermore, as the son of an American citizen (Ms. Stanley Ann Dunham), he fits the constitutional definition of American citizenship as a requirement for holding the presidency. The natural born child of an American citizen is eligible for the presidency, even if the birth occurred outside the US (e.g. in Panama as it did for Sen. McCain, or Canada, as it did for Mr. Cruz.)
For persons not holding automatic U.S. citizenship through a parent's nationality, birth in the U.S. also makes one a US citizen (per the 14th Amendment.)
It's hard to take your comments seriously when you perpetuate an untrue story.
(1) Anonymous, February 22, 2015 1:18 AM
Beautiful comparison